Case file · greenwash-co
Multiple major greenwashing tells found in this report.
This is our assessment of GreenWash Co.'s own published report, measured against the criteria below. It is an opinion grounded in a fixed, published rubric — not a factual claim about the company's intent. Every finding quotes the report verbatim or names a specific omission. Read the full method.
Scope 1/2 emissions are disclosed with figures, but Scope 3 is never mentioned — the value chain (typically the majority of the footprint) is omitted entirely.
A long-dated target (2040-2060) and a net-zero/neutrality claim appear, but no interim milestone year (2025-2039) is stated — a promise with no nearer checkpoint.
This claim states a reduction in environmental footprint without providing a baseline value or year.
“We have made significant reductions in our environmental footprint and continue to improve year over year across all areas of our operations and value chain.”✓ verified verbatim against sourceGreenWash Co. · Sustainability Report 2025 (synthetic test fixture)
The company claims carbon neutrality today, but explicitly states it is achieved primarily through purchased offsets, indicating a reliance on offsets rather than operational reductions. The phrase "overwhelming majority" strongly supports this.
“We are pleased to announce that GreenWash Co. is carbon neutral today, achieved primarily through the purchase of high-quality carbon offsets from verified projects around the world. Offsets account for the overwhelming majority of our stated neutrality.”✓ verified verbatim against sourceGreenWash Co. · Sustainability Report 2025 (synthetic test fixture)
The report uses superlative language such as 'industry-leading' and 'world-class leader' to describe the company's sustainability efforts without providing any supporting data.
“At GreenWash Co. we are proud to be an industry-leading, world-class leader in corporate sustainability.”✓ verified verbatim against sourceGreenWash Co. · Sustainability Report 2025 (synthetic test fixture)
| Tell | Severity | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Missing or unquantified Scope 3 | major | Scope 1/2 emissions are disclosed but Scope 3 (usually the majority of the real footprint) is absent or given no number. |
| Long-dated target, no interim milestones | minor | A far-off target (e.g. net-zero 2050) with no nearer interim milestone and no stated path to get there. |
| Unbaselined headline claim | major | A reduction or improvement claim with no baseline value and no baseline year — progress you can't measure against a starting point. |
| Offset-dependent neutrality | major | A 'carbon neutral' / 'net zero today' claim achieved mostly through purchased offsets rather than actual emissions cuts. |
| Vague superlative, no number | minor | Qualitative bragging — 'industry-leading', 'world-class' — standing in for any measurable performance figure. |
See the full rubric and label thresholds.
The dispatch
One short email when a company is added to the docket. No spam, no filler.
Set NEXT_PUBLIC_NEWSLETTER_ACTION to wire this to a real list.